Bink: Chloe, we gotta leave Santa some treats! I vote dried mouse tails.
Chloe: No way! I'm sure he'd prefer dehydrated rabbit tongue.
Bink: I bet he'd really go for jarred rabbit guts...
Reveal later that night. Santa is there with his cat.
Santa: Ho ho ho! Whiskers, it's another house with treats for you! Be sure to leave them a little something!